Malvern, Arkansas – A former law enforcement officer from Malvern has pleaded guilty to charges of misleading a federal agency. Derek “Scott” Finkbeiner, 47, the elected Sheriff of Hot Spring County, appeared before Chief Judge Susan O. Hickey in the United States District Court in El Dorado, where he admitted to one count of engaging in a scheme to conceal a material fact from a governmental agency.
Admission of Misconduct and Deception
According to the plea agreement, Finkbeiner admitted that between August 19 and August 24, 2023, he intentionally concealed material facts from the Federal Bureau of Investigation regarding his connection with an individual who was the subject of a federal drug investigation. The former sheriff acknowledged that he was present at the suspect’s residence during an FBI-controlled narcotics purchase and further admitted to using crack cocaine and methamphetamine with the individual under investigation.
Once Finkbeiner became aware of the FBI’s inquiry, he actively attempted to mislead federal agents about both his personal connection to the suspect and any ties between the Hot Spring County Sheriff’s Department and the target. His actions were aimed at persuading the FBI to halt its investigation, demonstrating a clear abuse of his position as a law enforcement officer.
Legal Consequences and Sentencing
Finkbeiner’s sentencing is scheduled to take place in approximately four months. He faces a maximum prison sentence of up to five years for his role in obstructing the federal investigation. Chief Judge Susan Hickey will determine his sentence. U.S. Attorney David Clay Fowlkes of the Western District of Arkansas announced the plea. The Federal Bureau of Investigation led the investigation into the case, while First Assistant U.S. Attorney Kim Harris, along with Assistant U.S. Attorneys Bryan Achorn and Trent Daniels, is handling the prosecution.
A Case That Undermines Public Trust
Finkbeiner’s guilty plea serves as a stark reminder of the consequences of violating public trust. His role as a law enforcement official came with the responsibility to uphold justice, yet his actions directly interfered with an ongoing federal investigation. His attempt to manipulate the system not only compromised law enforcement operations but also damaged the credibility of the agency he once led.
As Finkbeiner’s sentencing approaches, the prosecution sends a clear message that law enforcement officers who engage in unlawful activities will face the full force of the justice system.
